Best Bedding

Best Mattress Protectors in 2023 (Complete Guide)

NEW YEAR DEALS

bamboo sheet img
  • 100% Natural Eucalyptus Based Fiber
  • 100% Waterproof
  • Cool, Noiseless & Comfortable
  • 10-Year Warranty & 50-Day Free Returns
9.9
Offer: 50% (Ends Soon)
Offer: 50% Off
(Ends Soon)
Best Overall # 1
Ranked
protector
  • Padded protection
  • 30-Day free returns
  • 100% natural cotton
8.2
Best Padded # 2
Ranked
Degree 5 Bamboo Sheets
  • 360-degree protection
  • 130-Day limited returns
  • 10-Year Warranty
8.0
Best Encasement # 3
Ranked
Simply Bamboo Sheets img
  • Cooling Tencel cover
  • 3 High-end materials
  • 60-Day easy returns
7.7
Deep Pockets # 4
Ranked
Cariloha  img
  • 100% Waterproof & 100% Cotton
  • 30-Day free returns
  • 1-Year Warranty
7.5
Best Luxury # 5
Ranked

How To Find The Best Mattress Protector?

Not all mattress protectors are created equal. There is a lot that goes on in the making of mattress protectors so make sure you read these points carefully so you don’t get a bad quality protector that causes you to lose your mattress to an accident or even cause health problems and allergies.

These are the only tips you need to find the right mattress protector from all the pretenders: 

1- Stay away from Amazon Protectors!

We personally tested dozens of protectors and we can confidently say that the ones from Amazon are by far the worst. You basically get what you pay for. Unfortunately, because the businesses selling these are in China, they do not abide by the FTC rules. They say things like 100% natural while the quality is obviously just polyester. They even play with the law tags to show authenticity. 

Also, do not trust the reviews, as even Amazon itself said that those Chinese businesses are hacking their way into thousands of reviews and they can’t do anything about it.

To put it simply, stay away from all Amazon bedding. 

2- Natural materials are cooler, better and last longer!

Always go with a natural protector if you can. Natural materials are cooler because they don’t trap and keep heat like vinyl, polyester, or plastic. Look for things like cotton, Tencel, or Eucalyptus based fabrics. Those are cooler for sleep, cleaner and safer for skin contact, and best of all keep both you and the mattress protected longer. 

3- Good value mixed with good quality. 

A lot of mattress protectors will get the job done but be careful of those that use cheap materials. If the protector fails, it will cost you a much more expensive mattress. When it comes to protectors the saying “nothing is more expensive than cheap” is extremely true. 

However, all you have to make sure of is a natural cover supplemented by a laminate barrier and a great price. Synthetics cover will make you sleep hot while bad waterproof barriers like vinyl, or plastic won’t last past the first few washes. 

4- Reputation & Customer Reviews Matter.

Nothing is better than personal experience. When it comes to well-reputable brands like the ones here on this list, the reviews are honest because the businesses are Google partners. This means they cannot control and play with reviews as they are posted by the Google service. Also, unlike the Amazon sellers, they are American businesses and they have the FTC laws to abide by. 

Read their reviews and see what people like about these protectors. The higher the review counts, the more these protectors are desired. 

5- Service, Sleep Trial & Warranty. 

Look for a good service with at least a 30-day return policy with full money-back guarantee to make sure you like the protector. Also, the more years on the warranty the better the products and their manufacturing because these brands will have to keep their promises or get in trouble. This means that if they offer good warranties it is because the product is of good quality.  

bamboo sheet img
  • 100% Natural Eucalyptus Based Fiber
  • 100% Waterproof
  • Cool, Noiseless & Comfortable
  • 10-Year Warranty & 50-Day Free Returns
9.9
Offer: 50% (Ends Soon)
Offer: 50% Off
(Ends Soon)
Best Overall # 1
Ranked

We may receive a referral fee each time a consumer uses a link or code on this website to purchase a product with, for more info visit our disclosure page.

image of sara

Sarah Taylor

After years of not sleeping well and not finding the right guide for natural products online, she decided to do the research so others don’t suffer when buying a new mattress as she did. For the past 3 years, she studied everything about sleep and natural product to put the best natural mattress buying guide online.

+
logo of sweetzzz

Get 35% off

Sweet Zzz Cooling

Mattress Protector

Shop Now

Write A Comment