1- Sweet Zzz Cooling Mattress protector
- 100% Natural Eucalyptus Based Fiber
- 100% Waterproof
- Cool, Noiseless & Comfortable
- 10-Year Warranty & 50-Day Free Returns
TopProtector5
TopProtector5
Ranked
Bottomline:
For a mattress protector to have the perfect score, it needs to be soft to the touch, cool, offers protection, has no noise, and comes at a great price. All of these features are in the Sweet Zzz Cooling protector, and that is why it is our best pick.
Performance:
We tested this protector with various methods to see if it protected the mattress, and we are very happy with the results. The mattress was in perfect condition and dry.
As far as cooling and comfort, we noticed that this protector sleeps noticeably cooler because it is made from natural 100% eucalyptus-based fiber.
Also, we didn’t notice any noise from this protector because the barrier is made of laminate. The ones we got from Amazon, for example, use plastic vinyl for protection, and those are both bad for the health and make a lot of noise. That is why we didn’t include any of them in this list.
What is it made of:
The Sweet Zzz Cooling protector cover is made from Tencel. A 100% eucalyptus-based fiber that stays both cool and dry for the best sleep experience. A lot of athletic clothing uses Tencel because of its amazing ability to keep your body cool and dry.
The barrier part of this protector is made of laminate which is the most durable and sustainable barrier material available.
The protector is also certified safe for babies and those with sensitive skin.
Value & Services:
Despite the Sweet Zzz protector being natural, durable, and cooling, the price tag is actually very generous; we feel like it is a great value for the money.
It also comes with a 50-night sleep trial where you pay nothing in case of a return (not even the shipping and handling) and a 10-year warranty.
2- Plushbeds Mattress Protector
Ranked
Bottomline:
If budget is no issue for you, then this mattress protector should be on your radar. This is another great sustainable way to protect your mattress and stay comfortable. It has a lovely natural cotton and wool fill and cover and a laminate protector. However, it does change the feel of the mattress by making it slightly softer.
Performance:
During our tests, we found this protector to be doing a beautiful job at protecting the mattress and keeping both fresh and dry. However, because it is slightly padded, it can sometimes feel humid and requires more regular washing than a Tencel protector.
Though there was very little noise from this protector, none of the testers said it gets in the way of having a good night’s sleep. Overall the performance of this protector was very good.
What is it made of:
The Plushbeds protector cover is made from natural cotton and wool and is certified safe. The cover feels very luxurious and does add a little padding to the mattress. You shouldn’t depend on this if you think it would drastically change the feel of your bed, but rather think of it as a nice little padding for a luxury feel.
The barrier is made of laminate which is the safest way of doing a protector’s barrier.
Value & Services:
If there is one negative we could give this protector, it would have to be the price. Though it offers an amazing number of features, the price tag is a little high when compared to other models.
This protector comes with a 10-year warranty.
3- Naturepedic Mattress Protector
Ranked
Bottomline:
If you want to protect your mattress and do so sustainably, you should consider this protector. Though it is more on the pricy side, it offers a completely eco-friendly way of protecting your mattress. The best part, it does its job beautifully.
Performance:
Protection-wise, this one is very good as it allows nothing to get to the mattress. However, it did feel a little warm at times and came to make a little bit of noticeable noise.
Though not as cool as Tencel, this cotton protector feels very luxurious.
Value & Services:
For the all-sustainable protection that this mattress protector offers, we feel that it has fair value. Do note, however, that Mattress protector comes with a 30-day return policy only so make sure to decide on wether or not your going to keep in in the first couple of weeks.
4- Amerisleep Mattress Protector
Ranked
A lot of research and development went into this mattress protector, and the way its design is certainly worthy of mention. Using a high end temperature-regulation technology to cool the bed while actively shielding the mattress from dirt, spills, and daily use.
The cooling fabric is somewhat like the Tencel fabric in its ability to absorb moisture and keep the bed dry. It is also known for its good durability.
The Amerisleep Mattress Protector is generally one of the most innovative protectors out there and comes with a 10-year warranty and free shipping.
5- Sleep and Beyond Protector
Ranked
This Organic mattress protector is made of 100% natural wool and eco-friendly materials. filled with 100% washable wool, and offers great breathability resulting in maintained core body temperatures without overheating. We never noticed that it was causing any heating or heat-trapping issues.
Being natural also means that it is very sturdy. This protector by Sleep and Beyond has a 10-year warranty and was 100% waterproof when we tested it.
Also, just like the previously mentioned protector, it has no dyes or harsh chemicals.
If budget is not an issue, then this one is surely worth a try.
How To Find The Best Mattress Protector?
Not all mattress protectors are created equal. There is a lot that goes on in the making of mattress protectors so make sure you read these points carefully so you don’t get a bad quality protector that causes you to lose your mattress to an accident or even cause health problems and allergies.
These are the only tips you need to find the right mattress protector from all the pretenders:
1- Stay away from Amazon Protectors!
We personally tested dozens of protectors and we can confidently say that the ones from Amazon are by far the worst. You basically get what you pay for. Unfortunately, because the businesses selling these are in China, they do not abide by the FTC rules. They say things like 100% natural while the quality is obviously just polyester. They even play with the law tags to show authenticity.
Also, do not trust the reviews, as even Amazon itself said that those Chinese businesses are hacking their way into thousands of reviews and they can’t do anything about it.
To put it simply, stay away from all Amazon bedding.
2- Natural materials are cooler, better and last longer!
Always go with a natural protector if you can. Natural materials are cooler because they don’t trap and keep heat like vinyl, polyester, or plastic. Look for things like cotton, Tencel, or Eucalyptus based fabrics. Those are cooler for sleep, cleaner and safer for skin contact, and best of all keep both you and the mattress protected longer.
3- Good value mixed with good quality.
A lot of mattress protectors will get the job done but be careful of those that use cheap materials. If the protector fails, it will cost you a much more expensive mattress. When it comes to protectors the saying “nothing is more expensive than cheap” is extremely true.
However, all you have to make sure of is a natural cover supplemented by a laminate barrier and a great price. Synthetics cover will make you sleep hot while bad waterproof barriers like vinyl, or plastic won’t last past the first few washes.
4- Reputation & Customer Reviews Matter.
Nothing is better than personal experience. When it comes to well-reputable brands like the ones here on this list, the reviews are honest because the businesses are Google partners. This means they cannot control and play with reviews as they are posted by the Google service. Also, unlike the Amazon sellers, they are American businesses and they have the FTC laws to abide by.
Read their reviews and see what people like about these protectors. The higher the review counts, the more these protectors are desired.
5- Service, Sleep Trial & Warranty.
Look for a good service with at least a 30-day return policy with full money-back guarantee to make sure you like the protector. Also, the more years on the warranty the better the products and their manufacturing because these brands will have to keep their promises or get in trouble. This means that if they offer good warranties it is because the product is of good quality.
- 100% Natural Eucalyptus Based Fiber
- 100% Waterproof
- Cool, Noiseless & Comfortable
- 10-Year Warranty & 50-Day Free Returns
TopProtector5
TopProtector5
Ranked
We may receive a referral fee each time a consumer uses a link or code on this website to purchase a product with, for more info visit our disclosure page.
Sarah Taylor
After years of not sleeping well and not finding the right guide for natural products online, she decided to do the research so others don’t suffer when buying a new mattress as she did. For the past 3 years, she studied everything about sleep and natural product to put the best natural mattress buying guide online.
